Dreaming on my back
Over the past couple of years, I have become increasingly aware of a curious phenomenon: when I sleep on my back, I tend to have more vivid dreams than when I sleep on my side or chest. I don’t mean vivid as in “nightmare” — it’s been a long time since I’ve had a nightmare — I just mean that they seem more colorful, have better plots, have better sound, and generally are more intense.
Ordinarily, I find my sides and my chest to be more comfortable than my back for sleeping, but every once in a while some good back sleep fits the bill. Sometimes I’ll drift off to sleep while on my back. Other times I’ll go to sleep not on my back but wake up mid-dream and find myself on my back.
There are a variety of potential issues with my observed back-sleep–vivid-dreams correlation:
- There could be a strong reporting bias — if I sleep on my back and don’t have a vivid dream, the event passes unnoticed.
- The occurrence of vivid dreams on the back could be no higher than in any other position, but they might seem more notable because I tend not to sleep on my back.
- Dreams are highly personal experiences, so external observation and objective measurement are impossible.
- Correlation is not causation — perhaps having vivid dreams causes me to sleep on my back, not the other way around.
- The back dreams might not actually be any more vivid than dreams in other positions, as quantifying dream vividness is fraught with challenges.
- There might be something about sleeping on my back that simply makes me more likely to remember my dreams.
The final item in the list could be crucial: what if something about me sleeping on my back simply makes me more likely to remember a dream? That implies that something is causing me to wake up during the dream. As it turns out, I am aware of just such a thing: snoring.
I snore. I’ve never heard myself snore, but I know from the accounts of others (and midnight jabs in the side) that I snore. (If I snore like my grandpa snored, then — well, I apologize. I hope it isn’t that bad.) Anyway, I’ve noticed that I’m more likely to snore when I sleep on my back. Assuming that I really am having more vivid dreams while sleeping on my back, perhaps they are related to my snoring.
Maybe the snoring noise is seeding the dreams with information on which to operate. Perhaps my snoring is waking me up, causing me to remember the dreams. Perhaps my snoring wakes other people up, which causes them to jab me and wake me up, which would also lead me to remember the dreams. Or maybe something about the snoring is affecting oxygen levels in my brain and thus its behavior.
I post this not because I have answers but because I have questions. A search of the literature produced no promising leads, so the next step is to find out: am I alone? Have others experienced predictable dreaming changes based on their bodies’ positions during sleep?
I definitely find that I have much more vivid dreams when my environment or mental state doesn’t allow me to sleep as deeply. The best for me are when I leave a light on. I’ve theorized that the amount of light that gets through my eyelids is enough to stimulate the optic nerve enough that my brain has to process it (as the visual part of my dream) even though I’m asleep, as well as keeping me from staying in a deeper sleep state as long. As you suggested, snoring could be providing both dream stimulus and keeping you in REM sleep. It could also just be that the fact that you’re not as comfortable on your back as in other sleeping positions is keeping you from falling into deeper sleep states.
Start keeping a dream log! I guarantee the mere act of keeping a dream log will increase the number of vivid dreams – observer effect of some sort? – so if you do keep a log make sure you control for this.
Snoring + waking up is a precursor for sleep apnea, I believe (waking up b/c you stop breathing).
I second Isaac’s suggestion of a dream log. For less biased data, you may want to consider a sleep study (or two — one back sleeping, one side sleeping). Also, I’ve seen some iphone apps that claim to analyze your sleep patterns based on your night movements (Sleep Cycle is one that shows up on a google search).
@Isaac I think you might be onto something there. I sleep especially well with a fan running. It might just be that the fan drowns out all other noises, or it could be that the white noise from the fan seeds my brain much as the light might do for yours. More data is needed.
@jumi You’re probably right about the sleep apnea, but I’m not too worried about it right now. Only rarely do I wake up in the middle of the night, and on most mornings I feel completely refreshed. Still, it’s something for me to keep in mind for the future.
I have been experiencing the same thing for a while now. Whenever I wake up after a dream, I am always on my back, even if I went to sleep on my side. My dreams are normal, good dreams with no nightmares. I haven’t found any medical explanations as to why this happens. Any thoughts?